Longhouse Lodge Motel

3625 State Route 14

Guest rating: 7.08

Watkins Glen Harbor Hotel

16 North Franklin Street

Guest rating: 9.21

Idlwilde Inn

One Lakeview Avenue

Guest rating: 9

Longhouse Manor Bed & Breakfast

3137 Abrams Rd.

Guest rating: 7.95

The Colonial Inn & Motel

701 North Franklin Sreet