Best Western Plaza Hotel Saugatuck

3457 Blue Star Highway

Guest rating: 5.94

Shangrai-la Motel

6190 Blue Star Highway

Timberline Motel

3353 Bluestar Highway

Guest rating: 5.45

Hidden Garden Cottages & Suites

247 Butler Street

Guest rating: 9.54

Twin Gables Inn

900 Lake Street

Guest rating: 8.11

Maplewood Hotel

428 Butler Street

Guest rating: 7.6