Pequot Hotel

19 Pequot Avenue

Guest rating: 8.05

Tivoli Inn

125 Circuit Avenue

Guest rating: 7

Island Inn Oak Bluffs

Beach Road

Martha’s Vineyard Surfside Motel

7 Oak Bluffs Ave

Guest rating: 5.78

Isabelle’s Beach House

83 Seaview Avenue

Guest rating: 9.2

A Bed and Breakfast Afloat

Circuit Avenue Extension, Slip 69

Martha’s Vineyard Resort

111 New York Ave

Guest rating: 6.4

The Capricorn House

79 Seaview Ave

The Dockside Inn

9 Circuit Ave Extension

Narragansett House

46 Narragansett Ave., PO Box 2478