Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina

32 Star Island Road

Guest rating: 6.71

Sole East Resort

90 Second House Rd

Guest rating: 6.09

Beachcomber Resort At Montauk

PO Box 348 727 Old Montauk Highway

Guest rating: 7.37

Sun ’N’ Sound

22 Soundview Drive

Guest rating: 6.7

A Wave Inn

32 Elmwood Avenue

Guest rating: 5.9

Driftwood on the Ocean Resort Montauk

2178 Montauk Highway

Guest rating: 6.5

Surf Club Resort

20 Surfside Avenue

Guest rating: 7

Ocean Beach Resort Montauk

108 South Emerson Avenue, P.O. Box 670

Guest rating: 6.93

Royal Atlantic Beach Resort Hotel

126 South Emerson Avenue

Guest rating: 5.8

Born Free Motel

115 South Emerson Avenue

Guest rating: 7.2

Sole East Beach

107 South Emerson Avenue

Guest rating: 5.1

Ocean Resort Inn

95 S. Emerson Ave

Guest rating: 8.2

Kenny’s Tipperary Inn

432 W Lake Dr

Beach Plum Resort

779 Old Montauk Highway

Guest rating: 7.1

Atlantic Terrace

21 Surfside Place

Gurney’s Inn Resort Spa and Conference Center

290 Old Montauk Highway

Ruschmeyer’s

161 Second House Road