Clarion Carriage House Inn

227 Upper Main St.

Guest rating: 7.74

Kelley House

23 Kelley Street

Guest rating: 8.73

Vineyard Square Hotel & Suites

38 North Water Street

Guest rating: 6.41

Winnetu Oceanside Resort

31 DUNES ROAD

Guest rating: 8.5

Harbor View Hotel & Resort

131 North Water Street

Guest rating: 8.78

Edgartown Lodge

68 Winter Street

Guest rating: 8

The Hob Knob

128 Main Street