The Chalfonte

301 Howard Street

Guest rating: 5.99

Congress Hall

251 Beach Avenue

Guest rating: 7.83

Marquis De Lafayette Hotel

501 Beach Avenue

Guest rating: 5.97

Montreal Inn Cape May

1025 Beach Avenue

Guest rating: 7.85

Sandpiper Beach Club Hotel Cape May

11 W. Beach Drive

Guest rating: 7.81

The Star Inn Cape May

29 Perry Street

Guest rating: 8.78

The Virginia Hotel

25 Jackson Street

Guest rating: 8.54

Carroll Villa Hotel

19 Jackson Street

Guest rating: 7.66

Palace Hotel Cape May

1101 BEACH AVE

Guest rating: 6.42

Beach Shack

205 Beach Avenue

Guest rating: 7.76

Madison Avenue Beach Club Motel

605 Madison Avenue

Guest rating: 8.69

Wilbraham Mansion and Inn

133 Myrtle Ave.

Guest rating: 7.64

Bayberry Inn Bed & Breakfast Cape May

223 Perry Street

Rhythm of the Sea

1123 West Beach Ave

Guest rating: 9.1

Hyland Motor Inn

38 East Mechanic Street

Guest rating: 7.63

The Jetty Motel Cape May

2nd and Beach Avenue

Guest rating: 8.1

Angel of the Sea

5 Trenton Avenue

Guest rating: 7.05

Ocean Club Hotel Cape May

1035 Beach Avenue

Guest rating: 5.94

Hotel Alcott

107-113 Grant Street

Guest rating: 7.3

Hotel Macomber Cape May

727 Beach Avenue

Guest rating: 6.9

Periwinkle Inn

1039 Beach Avenue, P.O. Box 220

Guest rating: 7.4