Four Points by Sheraton St. Catharines Niagara Suites

3530 Schmon Parkway

Guest rating: 7.92

Westlane Motel Thorold

13127 Lundy’s Lane

Keefer Mansion Inn

14 St. Davids St. West

Guest rating: 7.7

The Inn at Lock Seven

24 Chapel St South

Guest rating: 8.4