Sammy T’s Beach Resort

Bennett’s Harbour

Guest rating: 9.08

Fernandez Bay Village

Fernandez Bay, New Bight

Guest rating: 9.51

Pigeon Cay Beach Club Hotel Cat Island

Pigeon Cay

Guest rating: 9.3

Island HoppInn

Fernandez Bay

Guest rating: 8.8

Orange Creek Inn

Orange Creek

Guest rating: 9.3

Greenwood Beach Resort

Greenwood Road, Port Howe

Guest rating: 8.7

Hawk’s Nest Resort and Marina

New Bight, Hawks Nest

Guest rating: 8.4